So many review but most have only read 100 or less chapters and panning it - the novel is 3119 chapters long! From an alchemy/ crafting novel, this is one of the BEST novels around. This is why you have to be careful when you see low ratings on novels but most of the reviewers haven't given the novel a chance and mistakenly lump it together with all the other Chinese Novels.
This novel is DIFFERENT from other alchemy/ crafting novels because:
-
- Alchemy is relevant for 95% of the novel
- Alchemy is described in depth e.g. Materials needed, acquisition, concocting etc
- Not a put X ingredients in the pan and out pop the medicine novel e.g. Emperor's Domination, WSSTH etc
Just for the record I have read at least 20+ novels with alchemy/crafting including ISSTH, WDDG, WSSTH, CWaC, AEDD, SotTR, DMWG, ED, AST, BTTH, AWE, WotMG, MW, PMG, WoC etc
The ONLY other novel I've read with comparable alchemy is Immortal Mortal - that novel is more if you like an alchemist who knows nothing and has to graft from start, this novel is more for someone who knows a lot and such the emphasis is on the result rather than the journey. Both are solid styles, just a preference. A good analogy is do you prefer weak to strong or strong from start novels?
ISSTH and BTTH have solid alchemy but just not enough while WDDG is more about harem than pill concocting. Immortal Mortal and UMG basically have ISSTH pill concocting quality but the alchemy is relevant 90%+ of the novel.
So why are people panning it? Well, the martial path isn't as well done as in other novels and the romance is absent. If you judge this novel as a whole then a lot of readers can be off put but I came into this for the alchemy and as mentioned, its one of the better novels around which allowed me to read 3119 chapters worth!
This novel does have a couple of shortfalls though:
-
- No romance and long separation (its not really a harem novel)
- Slightly unsatisfactory ending - not as bad as Immortal Mortal but you can feel it being rushed and its obvious this is the author's first novel. There is closure though so its not a bad ending or cliff hanger.
- By last few hundred chapters novel is more about sword/ fighting than alchemy
- Only 900 out of 3100 chapters translated so if you don't like reading MTL wait a while - plus side its being translated on qidian which is fairly reliable
- Translation quality is average
TLDR: One of the two best alchemy novels I've read (other being Immortal Mortal) - I have read a good chunk of the mainstream alchemy novels - and if you don't mind a lack of romance and reading MTL this should be a must read. Not perfect but much better than most other crafting novels out there - don't be fooled by the low rating, most people haven't given this novel enough time.